Pope infalibility

The Truth about Papal Authority and Infallibility

False teachings go all the way back to the first century. We were warned by Jesus, Paul, Peter and other Apostles to trust the Holy Spirit for the truth — discernment. In my quest to uncover where the Catholic Church started going wrong — away from the Gospel of Jesus Christ — I had no idea, I’d uncover so much blasphemy and heresy. The Roman Catholic Church claims to have total authority over Catholic parishioners and the world. Therefore taking the word “catholic” to its meaning — “universal”. The “Councils” are infallible and have equal authority as the Bible. The Bible is “extra” — basically, non-essential. The Pope, known as the “Vicar of Christ”, claims supreme authority over the church and all Christians all over the world. He also claims that everything he says is “infallible”. Where and how did this supreme papal authority and infallibility start? Certainly, not in the Bible…

The Gospel Truth

Jesus came and told his disciples, “I have been given all authority in heaven and on earth.”

‭‭Matthew‬ ‭28:18‬ ‭NLT‬‬

Let God’s curse fall on anyone, including us or even an angel from heaven, who preaches a different kind of Good News than the one we preached to you. I say again what we have said before: If anyone preaches any other Good News than the one you welcomed, let that person be cursed.

‭‭Galatians‬ ‭1:8-9‬ ‭NLT‬‬

Pilate said, “So you are a king?” Jesus responded, “You say I am a king. Actually, I was born and came into the world to testify to the truth. All who love the truth recognize that what I say is true.”

‭‭John‬ ‭18:37‬ ‭NLT

He was given authority, honor, and sovereignty over all the nations of the world, so that people of every race and nation and language would obey him. His rule is eternal—it will never end. His kingdom will never be destroyed.

Daniel 7:14 NLT

21 Now he is far above any ruler or authority or power or leader or anything else—not only in this world but also in the world to come. 22 God has put all things under the authority of Christ and has made him head over all things for the benefit of the church. 23 And the church is his body; it is made full and complete by Christ, who fills all things everywhere with himself.

Ephesians 1:21-23 NLT

22 Now Christ has gone to heaven. He is seated in the place of honor next to God, and all the angels and authorities and powers accept his authority.

1 Peter 3:22 NLT

And the leaders of the church had nothing to add to what I was preaching. (By the way, their reputation as great leaders made no difference to me, for God has no favorites.)

Galatians‬ ‭2:6‬ ‭NLT‬‬

Where the Roman Catholic Church Went Wrong on Papal Supreme Authority

The Middle Ages

c. 340s AD – The head of the church in Rome starts to take on authority over all the bishops throughout the Roman Empire. If a bishop of a church within the empire did something wrong, the bishops from nearby churches would get together for a trial. Sometimes, the Bishop or Rome was not informed.

What would happen was the accused bishop(s), if found guilty, would then appeal to the Roman church. Moreover, that bishop, would then appoint arbitrators.1

Since Constantinople (New Rome) was the capital of the Eastern Empire, that bishop wanted equal standing with the Bishop of Rome.

440-461 AD – Leo I, he made use of the title “papas” where we eventually get the title of Pope. In 452, Leo was able to persuade Attila the Hun to let the city of Rome alone. But later the city would be sacked by the Vandals for 2 weeks, but the majority was left alone because of Leo. Leo is considered the savior of Rome.

494 AD – Pope Gelasius wrote that God gave both sacred and royal power to the pope and the king. Because the pope was accountable to God for the king — he crowned him — the sacred power of the pope was more important than that of the king.2

590 AD – Gregory I – First Bishop of Rome to take on more pope-like power – Gregory the Great – 1st to take the title of Pope. In “papal succession” from Peter, he was the 64th Pope.

1049-1294 AD: The Papal or Dark Ages

1049 AD – Popes installed kings and emperors – Papal Authority – No emperor or king could be crowned without the Pope or one of his designated representatives. There was no separation of church and state. The Pope had a say in government and military.

1073 AD – Pope Gregory VII – “Dictatus Papae” – declared papal supremacy over temporal rulers.

1198 AD – Pope Innocent III on Empire and Papacy: He declared that God created the sun and the moon — the sun to rule by day and the moon by night. Thus, he claims that God created the Holy See — or “pontifical authority” to rule over “royal power” by saying that as the moon derives its light from the sun, so the king or emperor derives his light (or power) from the Pope. “The further it is removed, the more it increases in splendour.”1

1202 AD – The Pope has to have a say in who gets chosen or elected king — to make sure it’s not someone who may have been excommunicated or cut off from the church for committing a mortal sin.

1302 AD – “Unam Sanctum” – “…we declare, state, define and pronounce that it is altogether necessary to salvation for every human creature to be subject to the Roman pontiff.” They are declaring this as the fulfillment of the prophecy of Jeremiah 1:10:

See, today I appoint you over nations and kingdoms to uproot and tear down, to destroy and overthrow, to build and to plant.

Jeremiah 1:10 NIV

The Truth…

That, was God talking to Jeremiah about that time and the kingdoms of the Babylonians and others that would come and rule over Israel and take them captive. The Catholics do love to take scripture out of context! Here’s what they skipped… Read Jeremiah 1:9-19… I also highly recommend the lesson on Jeremiah chapter 1 in ThroughTheWord.org. If you read the whole book of Jeremiah, you’ll see that as he faced kings and princes, he suffered imprisonment because the rulers did not like God’s warnings to leave their idolatry behind and worship Him only. Read the whole book and you’ll see the truth.

Continuing with the History of Papal and Church Authority and Supremacy

1294 -1517 AD – Pre-Reformation Era

Popes were very decadent — rich and powerful – breaking the rules. The Renaissance was brought on by the Crusades as the fighters started bringing back from the Middle East the art and cultures.

1302 – Boniface VIII – “…of the one and only Church there is one body and one head, not two heads like a monster; that is, Christ and the Vicar of Christ, Peter and the successor of Peter, since the lord speaking to Peter Himself said: “Feed my sheep” [John 21:17], meaning, my sheep in general, not these, nor those in particular, whence we understand that He entrusted all to him [Peter].”

Screenshot from video: The History of the Catholic Church.

1429 – Council of Florence – Pope has a primacy throughout the whole world; is the successor of “Blessed Peter, Prince of the Apostles; the true Vicar of Christ, Head of the Universal Church and of all Christians; received in Peter by the Lord Jesus Christ, the fullness of power to feed, to rule, and to govern the Universal Church.”

1439 – Council of Florence – Basically stated that only members of the Holy Catholic Church could be saved — no one can be saved unless he has remained in the bosom and unity of the Catholic Church.

Reformation Era – 1517 – 1648 AD

After the Protestant Reformation, the Catholic church leaders had a big problem. So, they convened the Council of Trent….

1545-6 – Council of Trent – only the church can tell you what the Bible means and what to believe. Only their interpretation of the Bible is true. They can spin it any way they want. They followed Augustine’s views that people were born inherently evil because of Adam’s sin, and they were slaves to sin, “utterly reliant on God’s grace for salvation.”3 Hey, they had that right! It became formalized dogma at the Council of Trent. The problem was that they still needed to buy “grace points” through the sacraments to be saved!

Original sin was a keystone of Catholic theology. It provided the rationale for the doctrines of…

  • The Incarnation
  • The Atonement
  • The Immaculate Conception of Mary
  • It explained the need for infant baptism and the spiritual realm of “Limbo” – which doesn’t exist, just like purgatory doesn’t exist.
  • It supported the view of the church as the sole source of spiritual redemption, Christ as the second Adam, and the prohibitions regarding human sexuality.”3

1648-1790 – Denomination Era

1856 – Pius IX “There is only one true, holy, Catholic Church, which is the Apostolic Roman Church. There is only one See founded in Peter by the word of the Lord (St. Cyprian, Epistle 43), outside of which we cannot find either true faith or eternal salvation. He who does not have the Church for a mother cannot have God for a father.”3

So, basically, he’s calling St. Peter a liar for this is contrary to Acts 2.

1863: They did give outsiders the possibility of salvation: “We all know that those who are invincibly ignorant of our religion and who nevertheless lead an honest and upright life, can under the influence of divine light and divine grace, attain to eternal life; for God who knows and sees the mind, the heart, the thoughts, and the dispositions of every man, cannot in His infinite bounty and clemency permit any one to suffer eternal punishment who is not guilty through his own fault.”3

1869-70 AD – Papal Infallibility – Dogmatic Constitution “past or aeternus” (or future) – “Every time a Pope as Vicar of Christ issued a statement on faith and morals, … he was making an infallible declaration… All encyclicals [a papal letter sent to all bishops] were dispatched ex cathedra (from the throne of St. Peter), and hence represented teachings that were binding for all believers in every age.”3

1961-1965 – Vatican II: Clarification on papal infallibility… Could the popes have been wrong on:

  • The divinity of Jesus
  • Apostolic succession
  • The Holy Trinity
  • Same-sex marriage
  • Contraception
  • Abortion
  • Human life
  • Canon laws

“Therefore, the dogma that was meant to bolster the power and prestige of the papacy eventually came to create a fissure within the Roman Catholic Church that would contribute to its collapse.”3

Vatican II put an end to the old feudal system giving the council of bishops, who had power over the Pope. Any papal pronouncements were to be made in accordance with the majority vote of the episcopate. The pope was reduced to a symbolic figurehead. The bishops, along with the pope were vicars of Christ. 3

Why have a pope at all? Like why have a president, when you have a cabinet — appointed by the president only, with no senate confirmation, who has equal power? It doesn’t make sense! I see all these as a bunch of power-hungry people only interested in their own status while being oblivious to the salvation of the parishioners — which is Christianity’s purpose in the first place!

Furthermore, regional or national gatherings of bishops have the same weight of authority as a papal proclamation.3

So, in review…

The Pope is the vicarious representative of Christ here on earth. Free to interpret, review, or extend canon law of the church –or is he? Final court of appeals is sovereign for doctrinal disputes. He alone could absolve certain sins, issue indulgences, and canonize saints.3 The Roman Catholic Church calls itself the sole source of truth for all mankind (built on lies – man-made “truth”).

“He [the Pope] cannot err in matters of faith and morals.”

Mike Gendron

If you’re not sure if you’re saved or not, if you truly want to be born again and have the assurance of salvation, receive the Holy Spirit, feel His Shalom — a peace that surpasses all understanding, and get a 1-way, non-stop ticket to Heaven after you die, or that you won’t be left behind at the Rapture, which can happen at any moment, this is what you have to do…

Believe. Repent. Be Baptized. Receive the Holy Spirit.

  • Believe — have Faith — that Jesus is the Christ and He died taking your sins away forever and that He rose from the dead 3 days later.
  • Repent of your sins — stop sinning! Do a complete 180-degree turn in your life and surrender your life to Him. When you ask Jesus to forgive you He will. ALL your sins will be wiped clean — past, present, and future! And All means ALL!
  • Be Baptized by water baptism — show the world and yourself that you have died to your old life and are born again in Christ.
  • Receive the gift of Holy Spirit in your heart.

Invite Jesus into Your Heart and Receive the Gift of Grace, Joy, Peace, and the Confident Hope of Eternal Life…

Pray this prayer humbly and wholeheartedly…

“Dear Lord Jesus, I know I am a sinner. I believe You died for my sins. Please forgive me. Right now, I turn from my sins and open the door of my heart and my life to you. I confess You as my personal Lord and Savior. I surrender my whole life to you and I will follow you for the rest of my life. Thank You, Jesus, for saving me. In Jesus’ name, Amen.”

Next Steps in Your New Walk with Jesus…

  1. Start reading the Bible daily to get to know God. If you don’t have one, I recommend the YouVersion, Bible.app and Through the Word app — both are free and have a lot of great Bible studies.
  2. Pray every day. Talk to God. Ask the Holy Spirit to guide you daily.
  3. Find and join a Bible-believing church — preferably a non-denominational one and be baptized!

Jesus Christ is coming back soon! Are you ready?

Soli Deo Gloria — To God Alone Be the Glory!


  1. Documents of the Christian Church, 1999, 3rd edition, Edited by Henry Bettenson and Chris Maunder
  2. Christianity Through the Centuries, Earle E. Cairns, 1996, Zondervan.
  3. Among the Ruins: The Decline and Fall of the Roman Catholic Church, by Paul L. Williams, 2017

Special Video from John MacArthur

This was recorded right after Pope John Paul II died.

48 thoughts on “The Truth about Papal Authority and Infallibility”

  1. Pingback: What is the Truth behind the Assumption? Revealing a Catholic Lie – Seek the Truth

  2. Pingback: After the Reformation of the Catholic Church: No Change at All – Seek the Truth

  3. Pingback: Urgent Warning! Escape from Catholicism Now and Run to Jesus! – Seek the Truth

  4. Pingback: Freedom from Rules and New Life in Christ – Seek the Truth

  5. Pingback: A Letter of Encouragement and Wisdom from Paul – Seek the Truth

  6. Pingback: How to Follow in the Footsteps of Jesus – Seek the Truth

  7. Pingback: As a Born Again Believer, Your Body is the Sanctuary of the Holy Spirit – Seek the Truth

  8. Pingback: Revealing the Christian Creed: How to Get Your Glorified Body – Seek the Truth

  9. Pingback: How did we Actually go from the Gospel of Jesus to the Mess we Have Now? – Seek the Truth

  10. Pingback: Where is Your Confidence? The World? God is Faithful in His Promises! – Seek the Truth

  11. Pingback: Truth: What Happened at the First Thanksgiving: the Providence of God – Seek the Truth

  12. Pingback: Do You Honor Jesus Every Day? Not Just on Christ the King Day – Seek the Truth

  13. Pingback: How Saving Faith through Jesus can Erase a Sinner’s Debt – Seek the Truth

  14. With all due respect, this is not what Catholics believe. You site Williams, a “a self-professed Tridentine or traditionalist Catholic”. I cannot tell if he is a sedevacantist or not, but sedevacantists particularly seem to exaggerate papal infallibility. Please read Pastor Aeternus IV:10. It is quite clear about the conditions.

      1. What I meant is the claim that all encyclicals fall under papal infallibility. According to the First Vatican Council, the Pope only infallible “when in discharge of the office of Pastor and Teacher of all Christians, by virtue of his supreme Apostolic authority, he defines a doctrine regarding faith or morals to be held by the Universal Church”. Conciliar infallibility only belongs to ecumenical councils, not local ones. Thanks for taking the time to reply.

        1. It doesn’t matter, does it? It’s still a man-made religion which means nothing when it comes to the Gospel Truth, Jesus’ authority over the church and that salvation is through grace alone — that’s what’s important. Do you have Jesus in your heart?

  15. Pingback: From the First Century to Now: The Idolatry and Evil God Hates Still Flourish – Seek the Truth

  16. Pingback: Matthew 23: What Jesus Tells the Pharisees can be Applied to Priests Today! – Seek the Truth

  17. Pingback: Exodus 32-34: How Angry can God get When the People Turn to Idolatry? – Seek the Truth

  18. Pingback: 1 Samuel 2: Those Who Are Supposed to Represent God Don’t Know Him – Seek the Truth

  19. Pingback: 1 Samuel 5: What Happens When the One True God Meets a Man-Made Idol? – Seek the Truth

  20. Pingback: 1 Samuel 7: Get Rid of Your Idols, Live Right, and Commit Fully to God – Seek the Truth

  21. Pingback: 1 Samuel 10-11: How the Holy Spirit Changes us to be Different People – Seek the Truth

  22. Pingback: 1 Samuel 15: What Happens When You Disobey a Direct Order from God? – Seek the Truth

  23. Pingback: Ecclesiastes 9: There is Life After Death. Where will YOU Spend Eternity? – Seek the Truth

  24. Pingback: 1 Kings 16: More Bad Kings Establish Evil Idolatry in Direct Defiance of God – Seek the Truth

  25. Pingback: Hosea 11-14: God Grants Blessings if You Repent, Judgment if You Don’t – Seek the Truth

  26. Pingback: Amos 3-5: God Never Delivers Judgment without Giving Us an Out – Seek the Truth

  27. Pingback: Isaiah 1-4: God Now has a Warning for Judah – Stop Your Evil Ways! – Seek the Truth

  28. Pingback: Isaiah 29: Have You Surrendered Your Life to the Potter’s Hands (God)? – Seek the Truth

  29. Pingback: Are Catholics Idolaters? According to God and the Bible, Yes, They Are! – Seek the Truth

  30. Pingback: Ezekiel 13: Have You Fallen for False, Religious Teachers? Seek the Truth – Seek the Truth

  31. Pingback: Lamentation 4-5: The Judgment of God Made Right, then a Plea for Mercy – Seek the Truth

  32. Pingback: Are Ash Wednesday and Lent in the Bible? Should we Celebrate Them? – Seek the Truth

  33. Pingback: Mark 2:1-17: Jesus is the Only One with Almighty Authority to Forgive Sins – Seek the Truth

  34. Pingback: Mark 3: Why is Blaspheming the Holy Spirit, the Worst, Unpardonable Sin? – Seek the Truth

  35. Pingback: Mark 5:1-20: Jesus, Legion, and the Pigs. From Demoniac to Missionary – Seek the Truth

  36. Pingback: Mark 6:1-13: Hear the Good News of Jesus Christ with the Right Attitude – Seek the Truth

  37. Pingback: Mark 7:1-23: According to Jesus, It’s Your Heart that Needs to be Clean – Seek the Truth

  38. Pingback: Mark 9:14-29: Lord, Jesus, Help Me! I Need to Overcome My Unbelief! – Seek the Truth

  39. Pingback: Mark 11: Jesus, Messiah, Savior and King Shows His Authority in Jerusalem – Seek the Truth

  40. Pingback: Mark 12: Religious Rulers Challenge Jesus and See Him as a Threat – Seek the Truth

  41. Pingback: Mark 14:12-72: Jesus, the Perfect Lamb of God, Facing the Cross, Suffers Agony – Seek the Truth

  42. Pingback: Mark 15:32-47: Jesus Died and the Temple Curtain Was Torn. Why it Happened – Seek the Truth

  43. Pingback: The Eastern Orthodox Religion: What are their Beliefs? Are they Saved? – Seek the Truth

  44. Pingback: Nehemiah 1-2: Ask God for the Help You Need. He Answers Fervent Prayer – Seek the Truth

  45. Pingback: What Happened at the First Thanksgiving: the Providence of God

Leave a Comment

Skip to content